I have put these on two times now and both of those times they have stayed on so well! They did not move for me on a windy day and the edges did not come up either! The only reason I give it a 4 star is because the first time I applied the eyeliner, it kinda burned and made my eyes water. I did not put the liner in my eye just where the normal eye liner would go. The product is great other than that so I recommend it especially for someone like me who does not do regular eyelashes well!