ALL THREE OF MY CHILDREN LOVED BATH TIME AND I AM STARTING OFF MY GRANDDAUGHTER THE SAME. THESE TUB TOYS ARE EXCELLANT. I KNOW THAT I WILL BUY MORE OF THESE. SHE LOVES TO WATCH THEM FLOAT AND MAKE WAVES. SHE DOESN'T RATTLE THEM MUCH BUT SHE IS FACINATED WITH THE TWO TONE BALL IN THE MIDDLE LOOKING LIKE SHE WONDERS HOW IT CHANGES COLORS. MAKES YOU WISH YOU KNEW WHAT THEY ARE THINKING? OVERALL I FOUND THESE A HIT AND I DO RECOMMEND THEM. WELL DONE TO THE SELLER!