When I saw these I thought they looked like the Stila Metal Eyeshadows but they were a fraction of the price. i was hesitant to buy but decided to give then a shot. I snatched them once they came in and for the most part, I was impressed. Most colors are very vibrant and work great but the pink and turquoise colors I had to build up bc they were so sheer. Overall I give them a 6 out of 10. Would recommend to anyone looking for a dupe for Stila metal eyeshadows.