Finally! I have tried just about every gel, pencil, pen, pomade, and Brow mascara on the market in search of a product that will actually allow me to create individual, real-looking eyebrow hairs. I literally have No eyebrow hair due to alopecia, and it's nearly impossible to find products that can create natural looking eyebrows completely from scratch, without looking like I'm wearing clown makeup 4 shades too dark for my skin tone. I don't follow the instructions on the box and touch all 4 prongs at one time, because the lines it creates are far too thick and meant to fill in actual eyebrow hair. Instead I use very light, whispy strokes using just the tip of the longest prong, and it allows me to create individual hair strokes that I apply sparingly on top of a lighter colored pomade. You don't realize how off someone's face looks without eyebrows, or with drawn on way to dark solid and obviously unnatural eyebrows, until you have to create your own eyebrows on a completely blank canvas everyday. My only complaint is that these claim to be waterproof and smudge-proof. There are in fact waterproof, as long as you don't touch it while it's wet. If at anytime, wet or dry, you touch your brows, they don't "smudge" in the sense that you'll blur or spread the color outside of your intended eyebrow lines. Instead the color just rolls up like pieces of an eraser do, then fall or wipe off completely, leaving no trace the color was ever there in the first place. You can tap or touch your eyebrows, but if you drag your finger or smudge them in anyway, prepare to lose your eyebrow.