X because I wanted something with more coverage. I bought a zagg until TA changed their design and I’m so glad I waited. This case goes edge to edge and my case does not interfere with it. I actually like this better than other cases even though it covers up the camera. My only complaint is that the instructions talked about suction cups being included to put on the case and no suction cups came with the product. Very easy to put on and the air bubbles went away quickly.