I had my kids trial some of these, it's a rather large pack so we will have plenty come Halloween, and they came out great. The only thing that they made a mistake on were the hand prints. They are miniature hand prints...so they just don't look realistic...and those look rather odd.
That being said, my daughters friend came downstairs with a burn/scrape on her cheek and I said 'oh my god what happened...' forgetting that they had taken these to play around with. So yes, the ones that are meant to look realistic come off pretty solid. And they are akin to the higher end/priced tattoo packs where you get a lot less in them.
The four stars is for the weird tiny hands...but the rest are five stars.