Seems like a good product but I'm not sure if I'm using it correctly since all the instructions are in Chinese, there was no optional instructions in English so I'm not sure what the other 2 liquid like products are or when to use them. The mask works great though but has an inconsistent texture that is hard to spread evenly but could be because I'm not using it right since I can't read Chinese so I don't know if I missed a step. Quality English instructions would be a definite step in order to be able to review this product more thoroughly.