Let's be realistic if you have something really stinky in your trash and leave the lid open like I do you're still gonna smell it.
Once you tie it up it makes it bearable to bring to the trash. No issues with the tie bands or breaking and we usually shove the trash from the bathroom in plus a box or two where it ends up looking like the front picture or worse, i.e. pretty overstretched.
I think you'll dig it