A butt plug is one of the easiest ways into anal play, but it is also the toy where safety rules matter most. The single most important thing, before size, material or features, is the base. Get that right and the rest is about going slowly and using plenty of lube. Here is what to look for and the models our shoppers have reviewed.
Safety first: the flared base is non-negotiable
Anything inserted anally must have a flared base or a wide handle that is clearly bigger than the body of the plug. The rectum has no dead end, so a toy without a stopper can be drawn in and require a hospital visit to remove. Never use anything anally that does not have a true flared base, and never improvise.
What to look for in a butt plug
- A genuine flared base. Look for a wide, flat base or a T-bar handle, not just a slightly rounded end.
- Start small. Beginners should start with a slim plug and a tapered tip, then size up over weeks, not minutes.
- Defined neck. A narrow neck below the widest point helps the plug stay seated comfortably.
- Body-safe, non-porous material. Silicone, stainless steel or glass are easy to sanitize. Avoid porous jelly/PVC.
- Extras. Weighted, vibrating and tapered training-set options exist once you know what you like.
Best butt plugs: our picks
Each pick links to its full review page with specs, photos and real customer reviews, most-reviewed first.
1. Luxury Jeweled Anal Butt Plug Fetish Alumimum Alloy Fantasy Anal…
4.9/5 from 27 customer reviews
2. 3pcs Beginners Luxury Anal Butt Plug Sex Toys Anal Trainer Toys Super…
4.9/5 from 15 customer reviews
3. Bitch Fist Dildo - 6.0 Inch Fist and Forearm - For Vaginal or Anal…
4.3/5 from 12 customer reviews
4. Silicone Dildo Novelty Anal Butt Plug Sex Toy, The Hand
4.3/5 from 10 customer reviews
5. Anal Plug Silicone Butt Plug,Riodong Anal Sex Toys in Black…
4.6/5 from 10 customer reviews
6. Anal Plug for Beginners,Luxury Jewelry Design Small Super Stainless…
4.8/5 from 5 customer reviews
7. Vibrating Anal Butt Plug and Massager, Tracy’s Dog 10 Speed Silicone…
5.0/5 from 4 customer reviews
8. Tracy's Dog Anal Plug Trainer Kit, 3 PCS Metal Jeweled Fetish Butt…
5.0/5 from 4 customer reviews
9. Diablo Strong Dual Motor Prostate Massager for Men 10 Speed Anal Sex…
5.0/5 from 4 customer reviews
10. Butt Plug Prostate Stimulator with Large Mushroom Shaped Head for…
5.0/5 from 2 customer reviews
11. XINGHAOYA Male Vibrating Prostate Massager Anal Sex Toys 2 Powerful…
4.0/5 from 2 customer reviews
12. Prostate Massager Male Vibrating Feelingirl Anal Vibrator P-spot Sex…
5.0/5 from 2 customer reviews
How to use a butt plug comfortably
The anus does not self-lubricate, so use a lot of lube, more than you think. Water-based lube is the safe all-rounder; if you choose silicone lube, do not pair it with a silicone toy. Relax, go slowly, and stop if anything is painful. Beginners often do best lying on their side.
Cleaning and care
Wash before and after every use with warm water and mild unscented soap or a toy cleaner. Non-porous silicone, steel and glass are the easiest to keep hygienic. Never share without sterilising or using a condom over the toy.
Browse more in our customer product reviews, all written by real shoppers.
