There was a nice selection of 12 different colors all individually boxed. Each eyeliner color was sealed & identified but a number, not by the color. The 1st thing I noticed was the eyeliners smelled very highly of a flowery perfumed fragrance that was so over powering to me, I did NOT try these eyeliners on my eyes, but rather just tested them on my hand instead. The colors are very vibrant & are easy to apply. They dry quickly & can be removed with soap & warm water with a little extra effort, meaning they do not wash off very easily & do require a little more pressure. The waterproof formula will likely withstand a good cry! The color selection is great, however the product itself has a strong fragrance which made me less excited to give this a higher rating.