This liquid eyeliner is amazing!! Not only is it easy to apply, it looks great! I love that it is waterproof and sweat resistant. I have a dry eye and when it’s cold out, it’s as if I’m crying...the tears just come out of my dry eye. I was thrilled to stumble across this! I love liquid eyeliner vs pencil eyeliner. This was such a great value as you get two for a great price!!